1
An anonymous letter writer threatens to expose a town’s rumored secrets. Is anyone safe? “48 Hours” correspondent Erin Moriarty …
source
45 comments
Don't care about the writing expert, once she started talking about the numbers etc it got into the woo woo. As the frmr. FBI agent said the central question actually is: How did the letters continue if he was in solitary? Either there were two and he got help in prison which is hard to believe that he could get someone to post 100s of letters for him IMO. This also has logistical issues, handwriting would be different and it also leaves room for a snitch later on. Or Occam's razor: He wasn't the writer. Paul also does not fit the profile of a guilty person in how he acted during investigation, there is also the witness account of the El Camino to talk about too. There's at least enough reasonable doubt for Paul to not have been convicted of this IMO. I think the Sheriff's office was too eager to close the case, and sadly the jury agreed.
Penelope Featherington, what r u doing here?
48 hours should get rid of this boring old women
18:45 that Snorlax aunt?
What happened after his death. Soyle
Well, that's sad that they don't do DN.A and forgot who really wrote the letters.That would approve it, you can't write letters why you're in prison.It's just not, you can't. They read everything before it goes out
I know we're all thinking this as we watched the show.But what have been easy to d n a those letters
Circleville, really? Sounds like a Town in a Seuss children's book a very bizarre one at that. Unsolved mystery proving evil hides itself well sticks together.
With all that evidence they have, won’t they attempt to collect DNA from the envelopes, stamps, the gun, etc…???
I always thought it was the ex wife.
Take away the violent threats in the letters…its “awful” to expose the awful things people are doing according to Erin Moriarity. 🙄
Dearest gentle readers…
I don’t think Paul Freshour had anything to do with the Letters or the trap.
This has,”Hell Hath No Fury Like a Woman Scorned written all of over it.”
It wasn't Paul. It was his wife at the time.
Was there anymore letters after his death? They didn't mention that…
Always been one of my favorite “mystery” cases Super bizarre
When did the letters stop?
The most agresuse acts from a parent is when you use your kids for your own self interest. Shame on parents who do that. How despicable and selfish.
I've been to prison. There's no way that Paul was able to smuggle hundreds of letters from inside. Especially if the prison kept him in isolation. But it is curious that they stopped once he got out
This is kinda creepy this is in my backyard
He had connections inside the prison system. He probably just knew someone who mailed the letters for him.
The writer has a lot of time in her hands.
I had to start this over 4 times. Don’t take your attention off it for even a minute or you’ll be lost.
A woman almost gets shot in the head and his take is…”what a great story!” Spoken like a true reporter.
I wonder if he would have thought the same if that was his daughter/wife/sister.
Its obviously the wife of Freshour, she had 10 hours a day to write that crap, had inside details only someone close to Freshour would have, had the creepy son she had influence over, and the dude was in prison and not send no letters for 10 years & his wife had access to envelopes & paper he may've touched at home.
Paul worked in as a prison guard for 10 years ,he had no problem getting those letters smuggled.
Anyone ever ask themselves, "Di I think killers or serial killers watch thes 48hrs episodes too?" Think about it: it would be very possible for them for some sick thrill. Sorry for misspell.
If drugs, weapons and women can be snuck in and out of prisons, letters certainly could have quite easily.
This Mayhew woman seems clueless.
Thank for video
And while he was locked up were the letters still coming or they had stopped
So his gun was stolen but he didn't reported it to the police
Clearly the writer can not spell …….
That spiral necklace disturbs me.
The writer had too much free time.
i love the "I'm not wrong" from the hand writing expert.
19:04…Kinda looks like "JABBA THE HUT".
So, did the letters Stop when Paul died?
I stopped paying attention for a few minutes. Now my head is spinning.
OK, YOU GOT ME…I ADMIT IT…I WROTE THE LETTERS.
Paul wrote the letters but his wife set the trap with help
This would make a dope mini series…I am seeing Reese Witherspoon like she did in little fires
Was the handwriting of Karen Sue, her son or her boyfriend ever analyzed? So much of this story points to her. What about the wife of the dude Mary was having an affair with?
Karen Sue 💯
Happy new year 🥳 2025