Why We Need Muslim Public Intellectuals | Dr. Nizamuddin Ahmad Siddiqui

The biggest problem here is to how to counter the fake narrative of the media what our intellectual or whatever knowledge will contribute in countering that and how to counter that a bigger population is has started already thinking the way media is portraying things to them how we are going to counter that narrative there is a question mark always.

At this critical moment in Indian history when minority status and rights are under severe attack, Indian members of the 'Muslim Ummah' are advised not to fight among themselves but debate decently and compassionately among themselves without feeling forced to erase differences of opinion.

To create internal tensions and conflicts and splinter Indian muslim unity is EXACTLY what regime and it's hard and soft supporters want.
Believe my analysis, I'm speaking as a Hindu 😅

I'm a Hindu woman, and I'm not sure if this channel and interviewer are representative of REAL Indian muslim interests because
1. The condition of Indian muslims today cannot be understood without connecting it to the history of the treatment and massacre of Kashmiri Muslims, and in that regard, this platform invited co-opted, morally corrupt Ruhulla Mehdi instead of the likes of Engineer Rashid who is still in jail and has condemned NC politics ……
2. He never interviews Muslim women of any ideological slant, as though Muslim women intellectuals don't exist, a very dangerous sign. Like seriously, why no Muslim women interviewed, Mr. Javed ??? The trolls here linking me to hindutva say, see the archive, excuse me, I already have and he does NOT interview Muslim women…. Looks like you haven't seen the archive yourself.

Anyway # Long Live Indian secularism
Jai Hind

#2:14:24 onwards is bearable only

Chahe jitni marzi intellectual khoj log Muslim community me wo apne Quran ki soch se bahar nikal hi nhi pate. Or jab tak wo rational ho kr nhi sochenge, bs jo ek admi ne bol diya or ek book me jo likha hua hai wahi sirf sach hai ye maan kr baithe rahenge aaplog ka beda garak hote rahega. Thoda toh khud ka mind use kiya karo bhailog .Apne haatho se apno ki barbadi, jahalat kb tk dekhoge. Be rational, guys . Time ke sath kuch chize hatani padti hai. ek hi chiz ko le kar baith jaoge toh phir yahi halat hoga jo aaj k time pe aaplog ka hai.56 countries hai muslimo ka but aaj k time research and development, you all are the most behind. Why? Because of rigidity. flowing water is clean jab wo ruk jata hai, ek jagah smells aane lagte hain.

17:23 kuran updated bibi ko maro ,4 marrage ,aadhi akl ,aadhi gavahi koi god ki iq level etna kam kaise ho skta h…. Today women pm ,bussines ,srartup,docter …..ye god ko pta hi ni tha aane wala time science yha tk pahuch skta h

App abhi bola britch time se incrochment ho raha hai app ki soch as a Indian nai hai as a muslim soch rahe hai

One does not have to read more than the hole book of these jihadis to understand their Jihadi mindset.

The greatest setback for Indian Muslims has come from religious leadership. In contrast, the political leaders of Bangladesh—like Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, Ziaur Rahman, and now the women leading the two major parties—have been non-religious in nature. Similarly, Pakistan’s key political figures such as Quaid-e-Azam, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, Nawaz Sharif, Imran Khan, and President Asif Zardari Baloch were also non-religious leaders.

In India, however, Muslims have often been represented by religious figures like Maulana Azad, various clerics (Molvi), and now Asaduddin Owaisi—who also appears more like a religious leader than a modern statesman. His party even carries a religious identity.

Muslims of India need a HINDI national secular movement or provincial, regional national movement led by professionals—advocates, engineers, doctors, or professors.
Religious clerics, with their narrow worldview, are not suited to lead a religious community in a democratic and secular country like INDIA

Allah miya ek fake entity hai

What’s a country? It’s cultural practices,native religion, its food and so on. When you destroy their places of worship, condemn their gods as false, convert people and so on … do you expect them to fall in love with you. Can you ever be mainstreamed? Can an alien religion and culture be mainstreamed? People have called out the bullshit about syncretism and living together in harmony – and the nonsense around the Ganga Jamuna Tehzeeb. It only meant Hindus watching silently while a community prayed in mosques that were sometimes built by demolishing temples. How long do you think this would last. It’s over. You’re equal citizens – and you’ll have to contribute “equally” to the country’s economic development. Theres a lot of an ugly history including the creation of Pakistan that you’ll have to balance with positive contributions. By asseting your identity you’re only doing yourself a disservice – because there’s an India that is focusing on space, IT, business etc. to whom you remain completely irrelevant. And they are the only ones who count. So it’s a tough one to solve. Impossible if the community doesn’t take the first five steps. There; that’s the truth. You are equal citizens – so please contribute equally. And then things might happen.

Duniya bhar ki baat karega ye log lekin asli problem k bare me kabhi baat nhi karenga tu log ka kuch nhi ho sakta

Indian muslim need reforms, in education, media, politics, and this all will possible when good school and College will be build in block level for girls and boys , but muslim community has not invested in such things. We should stop blaming others for our leadership failure, why muslim leaders have not made such school and College from 1947 , from last 80 years congress was ruling party, why waqf board not made school and College, they mostly build shops and sell them

Brother You say through your channel that you are a think tank media that reconstruct the discourse around human rights, culture, politics and religion.

Really ???
All your videos looks as you are reconstructing the discourse around one religion that is "MUSLIMS"…you yourself are not secular
Are you really think tank media of india…where are the problems of other religions such as sikhs , jain, christian, jews, parsis…how your all videos are about problems faced by one religion …your views and contents does not match with the channel's description…
First bring change in your thoughts..

Number of subscribers and views of this channel shows that muslims are in deep sleep. Very unfortunate 😢

Mughal chalegaye bhai. Ab kaam karna padega. Upar se Pakistan Banwa diya. Ab who cares? 😂. There is no longer a constituency that is interested. This podcast is a brilliant sleeping aide. I put it on when I want to fall asleep to sweet nothings.

Muslim intellectual is an oxymoron.

Simple thing is muslims have become so much radicalized that they have stopped using mind and started following religious bigotry. And root cause is education misleading one in madatsa

Are you not far right…biggest issues with muslims are they are staunch and dont have a respectable point of view about other faiths….we need a modern muslim outlook with literature science fine arts like in other religions

The music takes away from the Islamic theme of the effort. Just my two cents.

Awais Iqbal, Jafar Heretic these two are doing great job. But you will have to listen them logically.

I strongly believe that "jamiyat ulama e hind" is totally incapable to think beyond the "ganga jamni tahzeeb" they have no visionary mindset, talking about barelvis they have not even leadership at all, in this dangerous political environment they are still dying in piri mureedi !

I strongly believe that in muslim society we need "youth scholars" who have visionary minds who have deep knowledge about ISLAMIC fundamentals while having deep knowledge about geopolitics, regional politics, social awareness etc,

And practicing muslims from collage and universities need to come out and participate in political and social fields, else we are going to be witnessing worse consequences very soon.

India is a hindu nation.